Grandma Verkaik’s Sugar Cookies (a Christmas Cookie Exchange Link-up)


Today I am going to teach you how to make the Christmas cookies that our family has been making for about 50 years.  And I’m thrilled to share it, and even more thrilled to read all of your heirloom recipes and the stories that go with them.

My Aunts and Uncles have memories of these cookies that extend back into their childhood.  They remember eating them as children and then returning thousands of miles from college to help roll them out and decorate them together.

As for me, I can’t remember a time when these cookies weren’t a huge part of my Christmas.  My dad always made them at home along with 6 other traditional cookie recipes.  He had an affinity for christmas tree shaped cookies, frosted green with green sugar sprinkles. He didn’t like to get crazy with the decorating and I must confess I’m still partial to a good ol’ green tree.

Not only that, but every year growing up my Grandparents would rent a cottage for our family so that we could spend a weekend together over the holidays.  My Dad was 1 of 5 and I have 13 first cousins, so this was no small gathering.

We would play Euchre on card tables, spend hours in the snow and stay up late telling stories and plotting practical jokes.

At some point over the weekend we would roll out these Christmas cookies by the dozens and then spend the next 24 hour devouring them with hot chocolate from a huge thermos.

I love that because of my Grandparent’s intentional living, my cousins and I have these recipes and memories in common.

Last night, I passed these cookies on to a 4th generation and my own children helped me roll out the dough, cut the festive shapes and slather on the icing and sprinkles.

They stood on chairs, on either side of me as I rolled out the sticky dough on our floury countertop.  Caedmon tried to roll matchbox cars across it as I struggled to keep it smooth and cut in the trees and snowflakes.

They’re young, they’re new at this, they’ll learn.  They will grow up all too fast and they’ll stop trying to drink the frosting and eat the sprinkles out of the shaker.  These sticky, messy times will give way to a new season.

We will sit and chat together over the cookie dough, they’ll maneuver the roller for themselves.  I’ll tell them about the Grandpa they never met and his love for Christmas and the green tree cookies.

I’ll cry a little in that moment, as I’m crying right now.  I’ll stop talking, which is rare for me, and I’ll long deeply for my Dad.

I’ll wonder why our Christmases were cut short and then I’ll get a little angry and find a little peace all in the same difficult breath.

Then suddenly one year my children will be all grown up and I’ll be teaching them 95510547how to make the dough for themselves. They’ll travel home for Christmas and bring our grandchildren over to roll out the cookies and frost the green trees.

We’ll go for generation number five and then pray that I see number six too.

There’s something about the heritage found in these simple sugar cookies that reminds me who I am and who I come from.  May this is always the case with the Penny-Verkaiks.

Because they’re not just cookies, are they?  Somehow flour and frosting stops becoming something so easily explained and becomes something strong and powerfully grounding, so full of love and longing.

So this Christmas as you bake your cookies and share them with those who taught your hands to make them, may you thank Our Father for the gift of cookies, family and the thread of sugar that brings us all together.


Now for the Recipe

I’ll be honest with you and confess that until Wednesday I was never brave enough to make the dough on my own, I always just rolled them out and decorated them.  My Dad or my Grandma always made the dough for us because in our opinion’s they were the only ones who knew how to do it right.

I found that, if you follow the recipe, it’s not so bad.  Our cookies turned out great and the only mistake I really made was adding too much milk to the powdered sugar when I made the frosting, start with a drop of milk, you can always add more.

Grandma Verkaik’s Christmas Cookies (originally from my Grandmother’s friend Mrs DeBoer entitled Grandmas Holiday Crisps)

2 1/4 cups sifted flour (the sifting is essential to this recipe those who have skipped it have met their cookie doom) 
1 cup sifted powdered sugar
1/2 tsp salt
1/2 cup unsalted butter (at room temperature)
1/2 cup shortening (you may omit this and use another 1/2 cup of butter, this is the only time of the year that I use crisco because I replicate my Grandma’s cookies to the letter)

Cut all ingredients together, you may use a stand mixer for this part, I did, but Grandma typically uses a pastry cutter.

Now lightly beat 1 large egg

Sprinkle 2 Tbsp of the beaten egg over the mixture (no, not the whole egg)
Sprinkle 2 tsp of vanilla over the mixture

Blend all ingredients together and roll into balls to chill in the refrigerator for at least an hour.  (I made two balls which I wrapped in plastic wrap to chill)

When you are ready to make your cookies, roll them out onto a clean and lightly floured surface.  Do not over-flour your surface or it may dry out the cookies.

Bake them at 400 for 5-10 minutes.  They are done when you see them start to turn 95510541lightly brown around the edges.  Brush them with an egg wash (using your leftover egg) right after they come out of the oven.  (This way you can add only sprinkle and no frosting if you desire)

Let them cool on newspaper or cooling racks (if you’re fancy, but growing up, we never were)

While they are cooling, whip up some icing using simply powdered sugar and milk.

This icing recipe is a lot like royal icing, but easier and just as good.  Simplicity is nice sometimes.

Gather a bowl for each color icing and put about a cup of powdered sugar in it.  Add in the milk a teaspoon at a time, you want it thick but workable.  Now add your food coloring.

Decorate your cookies as you like, with frosting, sprinkles, none of it, all of it.

Just make sure to whip up a few green trees to keep the tradition alive.

So, this is a blog Link-up!  Now it’s time for you to share your cookie recipe, share your favorite Christmas recipe.  You know, the one you make every year no matter what’s swirling around your life.

Write about why it’s so dear to you, so special.  Tell us who taught you to make it and what it means to you.

Then link up with us here sometime this weekend or whenever you get the chance over the next week.

If you don’t blog but have a recipe to share, feel free to comment or email me  (leannerae at gmail dot com) your recipe story and photos and if I get some this way I’ll share them in a post next Monday.

If you’re blogging along with us, feel free to grab the cookie exchange graphic.

Now get baking, get sharing, I can’t wait to read all about it.



Powered by Linky Tools

Click here to enter your link and view this Linky Tools list…


1. Sarah Bessey. In Which I bake shortbread

2. HopefulLeigh: Peanut Butter Balls

3: Miss Banana Pants: Lazy Man’s Caramel Apple Pie

4: Strawberries and Yogurt: Santa’s Whiskers

5: Chicago Mama: Traditions (Grandma Betty’s Pecan Cookies)

6: Accidental Devotional: The Cookie Porch, Haystacks

7: Already in his hand: Cookie Traditions, Ginger Snaps

8: Non-Edible Cinnamon Cookie-like Ornaments Recipe

9: Retro Housewife Goes Green: Quick Cinnamon Coffee Cake

10: A day in the Life of Jennay: Mexican Hot Chocolate Sugar Cookies

11: Two Green Kayaks: Mary’s Sugar Cookies


  • Annette Skarin (@carinskarin)

    I can just see it. Smudges of flour on noses, a little egg-white dribble on the counter, sugar grit crunching underfoot, green food colored fingers, bellies jumping from laughter and silly giggles, mixed with waves of warmth from the lit oven. The knock on the door is just me.

    • leannepenny

      Come in, have a cookie or four! I’ll put on some coffee.

      • Annette Skarin (@carinskarin)

        Thanks Leanne, creeeeak, “hi everyone, you sure look like you’re having fun. Sure, thanks for the seat, mmm…sure smells good. Oh sure I’ll have decaf with a lot of milk…ohhh yes, I’ll try one of those sparkly green trees please. Yummm!!!”

    • Lisa K

      I think I’m going to try your Grandma’s recipe this year. Thanks for sharing!

      • leannepenny

        Give it a go Lisa, you won’t be disappointed :)

  • Pingback: In which I bake shortbread | Sarah Bessey()

  • Pingback: Fridays Are For… | two green kayaks()

  • Pingback: Fridays Are For… | two green kayaks()

  • Pingback: Santa’s Whiskers | Strawberries and Yogurt()

  • hopefulleigh

    Love this! Proud of you for making this recipe and passing it on to your kids. Our old favorites can be bittersweet when we’re the ones carrying tradition forward but it’s ever so worth it. I’m sure your kids will agree.

  • Pingback: The Cookie Porch | Accidental Devotional()

  • Pingback: Quick Cinnamon Coffee Cake | Retro Housewife Goes Green()

  • ChrisAnn and Kristin (@LoveFeast)

    What a fabulous tradition and we love that you are passing it on to your children. What an incredible way to honor your father’s memory. Thanks for linking up at our table! We like your company.
    Chris Ann & Kristin

  • Pingback: Cookie Exchange Link Parties!! – A Day In the Life of Jennay()